Mystic, Connecticut Things To Do: A Local's Guide
Mystic, Connecticut is more than just a charming coastal town—It’s a place full of history, great food, and cozy little corners that feel downright magical. Whether you’re here for the weekend or a longer stay, there’s so much to eat, see, and shop for. This historic, small town is sure to win your heart, especially if you visit during the Autumn months or Christmastime.
Here are my favorite Mystic must-dos…
WHERE TO EAT IN MYSTIC
Mystic is packed with delicious spots ranging from cozy cafes to fine dining. Here are the ones worth seeking out:
Nana’s (32 Williams Ave) – Best known for their naturally leavened sourdough pizzas (my favorite), which have a devoted following. If you’re lucky enough to visit in late summer, the Elote Pizza (with roasted corn, cotija cheese, and a little heat) is unforgettable. Beyond pizza, their seasonal menu often highlights local produce, and the house-made chai is rich, spiced, and comforting—especially on a cool evening.
Shipwright’s Daughter (20 E Main St) – Mystic’s premier fine dining experience, offering a polished New American menu that balances creativity with approachability. The atmosphere is elegant but welcoming, making it perfect for anniversaries, celebrations, or simply treating yourself. Their cocktails are crafted with care, and the chef’s use of seasonal, locally sourced ingredients means every visit feels fresh and exciting. While this place is a bit pricey, it's one of our favorites in the area!
Via Emilia (24 West Main St) – A warm, intimate Italian restaurant ideal for date nights. Seasonal ingredients, rich sauces, and a wine list that leans romantic with Italian classics. The lighting is low and cozy, and the portions strike the perfect balance between indulgent and refined.
Sift Bake Shop (5 Water St) – An award-winning bakery and an absolute must for anyone with a sweet tooth. Be prepared for a line, but it moves at a nice steady pace! While their pastries often sell out early, everything here is worth trying—especially the buttery ham & cheese croissant and the tropical guava and cheese danish. If you’re lucky, you might catch their seasonal specials like pumpkin brioche or festive holiday cakes. Grab a latte and enjoy your treat on their patio.
Drawbridge Ice Cream (2 W Main St) – This homemade ice cream shop is a Mystic institution. Located near the famous drawbridge, it’s a perfect stop while wanderingdowntown. Their classic flavors are consistently delicious, and the fact that it’s dog-friendly means you’ll often see happy pups enjoying a pup cup on the sidewalk! Maple is a fan just as much as Steve and I.
Deviant Donuts (2 Coogan Blvd Building 6) – Known for pushing the boundaries of donut creativity, this shop rotates flavors daily, making every visit a little surprise. The donuts are huge, fluffy, and decorated with flair—almost too pretty to eat (almost!). If banana cream pie is on the menu (my favorite), grab it immediately—it sells out fast.
B.F. Clyde’s Cider Mill (129 N Stonington Rd) – Only open in the fall, but worth planning your trip around. It’s America’s oldest steam-powered cider mill, and the cider here is unbelievably fresh and flavorful. Pair it with their warm, sugar-dusted cider donuts for the ultimate autumn experience. We have had our many tastings of apple cider and apple cider donuts and these are the best around! They also sell hard ciders and seasonal jams, which make great souvenirs.
Red 36 (2 Washington St) – With its waterfront location, this restaurant shines in both atmosphere and food. The menu is seafood-forward with plenty of New England classics, and the cocktails are refreshing. It’s one of the best places to bring out-of-town guests—the views of the marina make a lasting impression, especially at sunset.
Mangos (27 Coogan Blvd Building 8) – Don’t let the casual setting fool you—this is a pizza destination that rivals New Haven. Their dough has that perfect balance of chew and crisp, and the toppings are always thoughtfully chosen. Whether you grab a pie to go or eat it on the spot, it’s one of the best hidden gems in Mystic. This is also a perfect spot to eat after a long day at the aquarium with it just being a walking distance from the aquarium parking lot in the Olde Mistick Village!
Taquerio (30 Broadway Ave) – A converted gas station turned taco haven, offering creative street tacos packed with flavor. The vibe is casual and fun, making it great for a quick bite or a relaxed dinner. My current favorite is the queso + salsa and chips and the rice and bean bowl + chicken (make sure you get it with the green chili aioli.)
Daniel Packer Inn (32 Water St) – One of the oldest and most historic restaurants in Mystic, dating back to the 1700s. The cozy tavern atmosphere makes it perfect for a chilly evening, with hearty comfort food like shepherd’s pie and roasted meats. Make sure to ask about the guestbook filled with ghost stories—many swear the place is haunted.
S&P Oyster (1 Holmes St) – A true Mystic classic located right by the water. Known for generous seafood platters and perfectly cooked oysters, it’s a must for anyone craving fresh shellfish. Their outdoor patio offers unbeatable views of the river and drawbridge, making it a quintessential Mystic dining experience.
THINGS TO DO IN MYSTIC
Mystic offers a balance of history, culture, and natural beauty. These are the highlights:
Mystic Aquarium (55 Coogan Blvd) – One of the top aquariums in New England, famous for its beluga whales, interactive exhibits, and dedication to marine conservation. It’s family-friendly with plenty of hands-on activities, and the new Dino Seas exhibit is a hit with kids (though note that it requires an extra ticket). Plan to spend at least a few hours exploring. After walk over to Olde Mistick Village for food and shopping!
Olde Mistick Village (27 Coogan Blvd) – A walkable outdoor shopping village designed to feel like a step back in time. The cobblestone paths, colonial-style buildings, and whimsical shops make it a charming stop. Be sure to check out the general store for nostalgic treats, quirky gifts, and homemade fudge.
Mystic Seaport Museum (75 Greenmanville Ave) – A living history museum that lets you experience maritime life from the 19th century. You can board historic ships, watch blacksmiths at work, and even see traditional shipbuilding techniques in action. It’s a fascinating and immersive stop for history lovers.
Mystic Day Sails – Several local companies offer sailing tours, from short afternoon sails to longer sunset cruises. Being out on the water gives you a completely different perspective of Mystic, and the salty breeze paired with the town’s skyline is pure magic.
Downtown Mystic – The heart of the town, filled with boutique shops, cozy cafés, and plenty of New England charm. The drawbridge is the centerpiece—time your visit to watch it rise for passing boats, which is a surprisingly exciting event. It’s the perfect area for wandering without a plan.
Seaside Shadows Ghost Tour – Mystic’s original ghost tour, offering a fascinating look at the town’s spookier side. Led by knowledgeable guides, the tours blend history with hauntings and take you through historic neighborhoods after dark. Even skeptics find it entertaining.
Denison Homestead (120 Pequotsepos Rd) – A beautifully preserved historic home dating back to the 1700s. Guided tours share stories of the Denison family and local history, while the surrounding land feels like a peaceful retreat from the bustle of downtown.
Denison Pequotsepos Trails (109 Pequotsepos Rd) – A network of gentle, scenic hiking trails perfect for an easy nature walk. The wooded paths, small streams, and occasional wildlife make it a lovely way to slow down and enjoy Mystic’s natural side. Maple loves to wander nose first down each trail!
Shopping in Mystic
Mystic’s shops are filled with character, offering antiques, second-hand treasures, and local charm.
Mystic Flower Shop (2A Pearl St) – A magical, fairytale-like florist shop straight out of the movies! Each arrangement feels like a work of art. The florists often create custom pieces on the spot, using seasonal blooms and lush greenery. It’s a great place to pick up a gift or simply enjoy the artistry.
No Other Book (3 Roosevelt Ave) – A cozy second-hand bookshop that doubles as an antique store. Shelves are packed with unexpected finds, from vintage editions to quirky curiosities. It’s the kind of place where you can lose track of time while browsing.
Lost & Found (29 Broadway Ave) – My current favorite antique shop! Lost & found is a carefully curated antique shop with an eye for unique and beautiful pieces. Every item feels like it has a story, from old furniture to delicate glassware. Even if you’re not shopping, it’s fun to wander through and admire the collection.
Stay on Park (2 Avery St) – Hidden behind Nana’s in a charming pink building, this shop is a treasure trove of antiques and vintage finds. The owner has a knack for styling pieces so you can imagine how they’d look in your own home. It feels more like a boutique gallery than a typical antique store.
Pennywise (22 Greenmanville Ave) – A consignment shop that’s so good, many locals hesitate to share it with outsiders (me, I'm that local!). The selection is stylish, high-quality, and changes frequently, making it a spot worth visiting more than once. Prices are reasonable, and the thrill of the hunt is real.
Holly Hock Farm Antiques (45 Main St) – Located near Clyde’s Cider Mill, this shop is perfect if you love primitive antiques and rustic finds. The barn-like setting adds to the charm, and the selection changes often with the seasons.
Just Mystic (33 W Main) – A cheerful shop for Mystic-branded merchandise, souvenirs, and gifts. The playful atmosphere and photo booth make it a fun stop, especially if you want a keepsake to remember your trip.